- Bull Street
- Posts
- đ Etsy Gets AI's Shopping Superpower
đ Etsy Gets AI's Shopping Superpower
ChatGPT just became a cash register, and one quirky marketplace saw its stock jump 16% faster than you can say "artisan soap dish."
Evelio Silvera
September 30, 2025
Good MorningâŠ
OpenAI's new Instant Checkout feature handed Etsy (ETSY) what amounts to a free distribution channel reaching 700 million weekly usersâthe kind of customer access that would normally cost hundreds of millions in marketing spend, except Etsy gets it by simply letting an AI chatbot become its new storefront.
đ Market Trends â Wall Street climbs as investors brush off shutdown uncertainties
đ„ïž Market Movers from Fintech.tv â [WATCH] Boeingâs Regulatory Thaw: Is the Sky the Limit for Shares?
And nowâŠ
â±ïž Your daily briefing for Tuesday, September 30, 2025:
MARKET BRIEF
Before the Open
As of market close 09/29/2025.
Pre-Market
| 
|
Fear & Greed
Markets in Review
AI Rebounds, Wall Street Breathes: Nvidia Leads Tech Revival
S&P 500: +0.26% to 6,661.21. Nasdaq: +0.48% to 22,591.15. Dow: +0.15% to 46,316.07
The Big Picture:
After a rocky week that saw AI momentum cool, markets bounced back Mondayâthanks in large part to a recharged Nvidia (NVDA) and a string of M&A headlines that reignited investor appetite.
Nvidia rose nearly 2%, calming nerves over concerns that its $100B AI infrastructure ambitions with OpenAI might be outpacing real-world energy capacity. Micron (MU) and AMD (AMD) also surged, up 4% and 1%, respectively, hinting that the AI narrative still has legs.
Elsewhere, oil hovered near $92 as supply concerns persist amid geopolitical friction, while gold traded flat, a sign that investors are still cautiously pro-riskâat least for now.
Market Movers:
Electronic Arts (EA): spiked 4.5% after news broke of a $55B take-private dealâa reminder that M&A is alive and well, with U.S. deal volume up 29% YTD.
Etsy (ETSY): soared 14% after OpenAI revealed a new Instant Checkout tool powered by ChatGPTâproof that AI isnât just about chips anymore.
Oklo (OKLO): rallied 6% after Barclays called for a 32% upside, betting on the long-term promise of next-gen nuclear.
Novo Nordisk (NVO): dropped 3.2% after Morgan Stanley downgraded the GLP-1 giant, citing prescription fatigue and looming competition.
Oracle (ORCL): struggled to regain ground after last weekâs 8% slide, as skepticism about its role in the AI buildout lingers.
What Theyâre Saying:
âThe AI capex story is showing no signs of slowdown. S&P 500 remains well-positioned given its tech-heavy mix.â â Venu Krishna, Barclays
WHAT WEâRE WATCHING
Events
Today: Bureau of Labor Statistics - Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS) Job Openings - 10:00am
Why You Should Care: Job creation is an important leading indicator of consumer spending, which accounts for a majority of overall economic activity.
Earnings Reports
Today: Nike, PetMed Express, Barnes & Noble Education
Tomorrow: ConAgra Brands, RPM International, Acuity Brands
MARKET INSIGHTS
Leading News
ChatGPT Becomes Your Shopping AssistantâAnd Etsy's Stock Gets the Memo
Photo Credit: appshunter.io
Why it matters:
OpenAI just transformed its AI chatbot into an e-commerce platform, handing Etsy (ETSY) a 16% single-day pop and potentially reshaping how 700 million weekly users discover handcrafted goods.
Zoom Out:
OpenAI launched Instant Checkout, enabling ChatGPT users to buy products directly from U.S. Etsy sellers without leaving the chatbot. For Etsyâa marketplace that's struggled with user acquisition costs and conversion ratesâthis represents a potential distribution channel that could reach more consumers than its entire marketing budget combined.
The market's enthusiasm isn't misplaced, but it's worth tempering. Shopify (SHOP) will add over one million merchants soon, including heavyweight brands like Skims and Glossier, whose shares rose a more modest 6%. The divergence tells you something: investors see Etsy, with its artisan focus and smaller scale, as having more to gain from AI-powered discovery than established e-commerce giants.
Here's the behavioral finance wrinkle investors should watch: OpenAI claims products are ranked purely on relevance, not influenced by commercial partnerships. If that holdsâa big if, given OpenAI's cash burnâEtsy's quirky, one-of-a-kind inventory could actually outperform generic goods in conversational search. Humans asking for "unique birthday gifts" naturally surface Etsy's strengths.
Key Insights:
The Etsy thesis: Etsy's chief product officer Rafe Colburn called AI-powered shopping a "meaningful opportunity," and he's not overstating. The company's 2024 take rate of roughly 20% means every dollar of ChatGPT-driven sales delivers meaningful gross profit, even after splitting fees with OpenAI. The question isn't whether this helpsâit's whether it scales beyond novelty purchases.
The friction factor: ChatGPT's Agentic Commerce Protocol, built with Stripe, lets existing subscribers use stored payment info seamlessly. This matters more than it sounds. Every eliminated click in e-commerce typically lifts conversion by 10-20%. For Etsy sellers who currently lose buyers at checkout, ChatGPT could materially improve their economics.
The revenue reality: OpenAI takes undisclosed transaction fees while remaining unprofitable and burning cash on infrastructure. Translation: OpenAI needs this to work as badly as Etsy does. That alignment of incentivesârare in platform partnershipsâsuggests genuine commitment to making commerce a core feature rather than an abandoned experiment.
Market Pulse:
"AI-powered and agentic shopping presents meaningful opportunities for the online marketplace," said Etsy's Rafe Colburn, in the understated corporate-speak that typically means "we think this could be genuinely transformative."
Bullâs Take:
Etsy just gained access to conversational commerce without building it themselvesâthe marketplace equivalent of getting Amazon-scale distribution at Stripe-level integration costs. If even 2-3% of ChatGPT's queries shift to purchases, Etsy's TAM just expanded materially.
Market Stories of Note
Wealthfront Bets the Market Wants Robo-Advisors Again:
Wealthfront filed to go public Monday, testing whether investors have rediscovered their appetite for automated investing platforms after the fintech sector's brutal 2022-2023 reset. The robo-advisor pioneer boasts $88.2 billion in assets, 1.3 million customers, andâcruciallyâ$194.4 million in net income for fiscal 2025, proving that algorithm-driven wealth management can actually turn a profit when interest rates cooperate. The timing matters: Wealthfront joins Chime and Klarna in a fintech IPO wave that suggests the market has finally stopped punishing companies for the sin of being born during the zero-rate era, though investors would be wise to remember that UBS walked away from a $1.4 billion deal to buy this very company when sentiment soured in 2022.
EA Cashes Out at $210: Gaming's Biggest Buyout Ever:
Electronic Arts (EA) agreed to a $55 billion take-private deal led by Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund, Silver Lake, and Affinity Partnersâpaying shareholders $210 per share in cash and marking the largest leveraged buyout in Wall Street history. The 9% premium over Friday's close reflects what sophisticated buyers see in EA's franchises like Madden and The Sims: predictable cash flows from annual releases and in-game purchases that behave more like subscription revenue than hit-driven entertainment. For investors who rode the gaming sector's volatility, this represents validation that blue-chip game publishers with proven IP libraries deserve private equity valuations, even if public markets have chronically underpriced their moats.
CRYPTO
Fear & Greed
